What Is Religion?
What does it mean that God is omnibenevolent?
What does Christianity teach about evil and suffering? Evil and suffering could make Christians question God's omnipotence, omnibenevolence, or his omniscience. For example: If God was all-powerful, wouldn't he stop natural disasters? If God was all-loving, wouldn't he stop suffering? If God was all- knowing, wouldn't he. God's omnibenevolence raises difficult questions surrounding the origin of evil, or what theologians refer to as the "mystery of iniquity." If God is all-good, all- knowing, and all-powerful, then how did evil enter the world? Some argue that evil is not a thing so much as a deprivation of goodness. Others argue that in order for. 23 Jul The concept of omnibenevolence stems from two basic ideas of God: that God is perfect and that God is morally good. Therefore, God must possess perfect goodness. Being perfectly good must entail being good in all ways at all times and towards all other beings — but there remain questions. First, what is.
Whenever I read philosophy throughout history regarding God, I notice something What Does Omnibenevolent Mean In Religion have issue with: Philosophers in most cases define god to be omnipotent, omniscient, and omni-benevolent. The first two conditions are obvious: I can see where being all-powerful and all-knowing would be necessary conditions for a God. But why is it necessary that God be omni-benevolent? Of course the Christian god must be omni-benevolent, but then why do philosophers almost exclusively focus on the Christian god?
For instance, the problem of evil is that it seems like omni-benevolence, omniscience, and omnipotence are incompatible with evil in the world. But again, why are we assuming God to be all good? A very simple solution to me is that: There may be a God, but he may not be good. Do philosophers ever What Does Omnibenevolent Mean In Religion that position?
Why, from my admittedly limited exposure to western philosopher, to we place such prominence on arguing for the Christian god's existence or non-existence? One large part of the reason is the influence of Plato and his followers click the following article world religions. Plato's philosophy all centered around an abstract entity that he sometimes called the " Form of the Good. Later, Plato's Roman followers, the Neo-Platonistsplaced an explicitly religious interpretation on what Plato had typically described in more abstract, less personified terms.
This, in turn, influenced St. Augustinethe great African theologian who formulated much of what became foundational Christian orthodoxy. He had previously been exposed to the Neo-Platonists as an educated Roman citizen, and when he converted, he identified God as revealed through Christ with the Neo-Platonic "One.
These philosophies similarly had an influence on other world religions, including Islam. Since over half of the global population adheres to either Christianity or Islam, that in itself is enough to answer your question. I think they have done so because people like to think of God as compassionate and generous. Hinduism believes in God's benevolence too.
In fact, almost every verse sung in praise of a Hindu God emphasizes this with a profuse use of adjectives that attribute kindness, generosity and munificence to God. The idea that God is not just all-powerful, all-knowing and all-prevailing but also all willing to bestow His kindness and generosity upon his believers is something that can go a long way in motivating most people to believe in him. Philosophers who uphold God's existencepreachers, priests and prophets have probably understood this element well.
If god is god, then what it wants is what is good, by definition. God imparts value to the universe because it is the only entity with perfect knowledge and total power, two claims you seem to accept. Consider an argument between you and god about what is good.
Do you know more than god? Can you enforce your will more potently?
There is no way to exhaust God's love. This does not mean, though, that he accepts our modern idea of an omnibenevolent God. Leave a Reply Want to join the discussion? Christians believe in the idea of unconditional love.
So god gets what god wants. God decides what good is, not you. Article source what about "the good", the objective good that exists in the ether and which you are appealing to? The creator god supercedes that, according to the definition of the creator god. That said I agree with you that there is a contradiction in the "three omnis" that describe god - if you accept a fourth principle called free will.
However if you reject free will then that calls into question what the universe is for. Is god watching a movie that he knows the ending to? Is any creation responsible for its actions?
This is called "the problem of evil" and it's the most intractable part of monotheism theism if you apply a little reduction.
It's not called "the solution to evil" for a reason. Apologists on many sides have attempted to solve this problem for millenia. Gnostics who are not considered Christian by most Christians do away with omniscience, Calvinists do away with free will according to the only definition that matters, I would argue, namely the ability to do what god does not intendand the Catholics basically fudge it, saying the coexistence of the three omnis and free will is a Mystery with a capital M.
First, it was the 10 Commandments. GdM Mar 24 '14 at That is a possibility.
So the child's question, "Why do bad things happen to good people? That said, do you accept a creator-less universe? Many people do nowadays, but that argument is also not without demerit. The answer is quite simple, really: And in the Western world after the rise of Christianity in the Roman Empirethe only religion that you were sure to encounter was Christianity until the last few hundred years or so. So it is natural philosophers who wrote of God described him having the same characteristics as is found in the religion around them.
If they are critiquing or supporting religious views, typically the definitions of various ideas have to be the same, including the definition of God. I'm not sure what you mean by "place What Does Omnibenevolent Mean In Religion prominence on". People choose to write philosophy about many things. Some happen to write on the notion of God. Most Western Philosophers talk about far more things than God. God is an old concept, it probably dates back to learn more here dawn of civilization.
We know for example that the ancient civilization of Sumer worshipped Gods. Why, from my admittedly limited exposure to western philosopher, do we place such prominence on arguing for the What Does Omnibenevolent Mean In Religion god's existence or non-existence? God is a central concept to all religions.
Apart from that, it is an attractive philosophical question. It's been discussed by philosophers even before Christianity. Although I believe it was Abrahamic religions that originated the concept. Where did the idea that if there is a god, then it must be good come from, aside from the Bible? Benevolence is integral to any concept of a Creator.
The very fact that God has granted existence to the creation underpins the concept of benevolence. And as for the question of evil in the creation that seems to contradict God's benevolence, I believe Plotinus's theory of evil solves the seeming contradiction.
Plotinus can also be regarded as one of the non-Abrahamic pioneers of the idea of God's benevolence. Drawing upon his philosophy, we argue that God the One is in essence benevolent because all goodness emanates from Him, whereas evil stems from His creation i.
So evil is a necessary part of the universe. In other words, to ask why is there evil, is to ask why is there any creation. That means the substance of evil is within our very creation. To be liberated from this essential, structural evil, man should redirect his tendency towards material forms worldly attractions, such as wealth, fame, go here partners and pleasures thereof towards intellectual forms angels and ultimately the One Himself.
However that doesn't imply suppression of our natural tendencies as practiced by Catholicism but moderating them so that they don't act as impediment to realization of Intellectual forms and the One a practice taught by Islam.
Philosophy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for those interested in the study of the fundamental nature of knowledge, reality, and existence. Join them; it only takes a minute: Here's how it works: Anybody can ask a question Anybody can answer The best answers are voted up and rise to the top. Why have philosophers historically defined Learn more here as omni-benevolent?
So I guess my question is: Joseph 1 9. Doesn't seem very benevolent to me. Why poverty so profound that you have to watch your children die of malnutrition because you can't afford to feed them?
What Does It Mean To Be Omnibenevolent?
Why drones attacking wedding parties? Why two billion people without running water?
omnibenevolent - definition and meaning
If we had a benevolent God, I'd be more inclined to go here in him! You have already the answer to your question: Ancient Greek gods are not benevolent at all! GdM Mar 24 '14 at Scrollmaster - I do not think so At most, we can try with a "wild" reading of Freud; if we can "assimilate" some parts of Freud's works to a philosophy, we may say that he tried to revive some of the ancient Greek gods Eros?
My initial response is benevolent Gods have better marketing. That is selling a benevolent god is What Does Omnibenevolent Mean In Religion than selling malevolent gods, much as it seems that selling monotheism is easier than selling polytheism.
BBC Bitesize - GCSE Religious Studies - Evil and suffering - Revision 3
Really something to think about. Prasad Shrivatsa 2. This question I believe stems from an ignorance about the conditions of receiving God's grace. God is all benevolent but obstacles veil us from His grace. That's why we are told to pray and repent steadfastly to qualify for His Grace. The answer could be improved by giving evidence.